Queer politics need to embrace antiracism and refuse complicity with nationalist and militarist projects

-

"While the gay and lesbian liberation movements of the 1970s still aimed for radical social and cultural change, the 1980s saw a modelling of queer diversity along the lines of an ethnicized, multicultural politics of recognition (Taylor 1992). [...] It has been argued that neoliberal politics have taken central concerns of sexual politics inspired by the civil rights era such as freedom and liberation and remapped them in terms of privacy, consumption and domestic bliss (Gluckman and Reed 21997; Duggan 2003; Richardson 2004, 2005; Katz 2005; Weiss 2008; Engel 2009). The fight for equality has by now taken centre stage for mainstream LGBT organizations in North America and Western Europe, the argument being that gays and lesbians are, and need to be recognized as, responsible citizens like any (heterosexual) other. [...] 

When in 1997, organizers of the main gay pride parade [...] [in Berlin] started to demand fees for participating floats, rebel protesters were relegated to the end of the march. They and other, including migrant, queer groups in turn decided to start an alternative gay pride parade called the Transgenial Christopher Street Day (CSD) and more recently simply Kreuzberg CSD, to protest against the growing commercialization and white homonormativity of the mainstream pride event, [...]. The Kreuzberg CSD, which has been drawing crowds of 2,000–5,000 people, has been marked by the absence of corporate sponsoring and political parties, and by the conjunction of political issues beyond the fight against homophobia: racism, gentrification and poverty are concerns that each year figure prominently in speeches and on banners. [...]

In 2010 philosopher and gender theorist Judith Butler was invited by the organizers of the main pride parade to be honoured with the ‘civil courage award’ that is presented each year at the march to individuals or institutions that have made special contributions to gay and lesbian causes. Up on stage near the Brandenburg Gate, in front of several hundred thousand participants, Butler refused the award, stating that she had only now been made aware of the overly commercialized character of the main pride parade and the racist as well as imperialist positions that many of the participating organizations embraced by refusing to see antiracism as a central part of their work. Queer politics need to embrace antiracism and refuse complicity with nationalist and militarist projects, she argued, [...]". 

Kira Kosnick (2015), "A Clash of Subcultures? Questioning Queer Muslim Antagonisms in the Neoliberal City", in International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 39(4): 692, 693 and 696.

Image: A banner drop and rainbow at Vauxhall Bridge in London on 20 January 2016, to show solidarity with all the people affected by the rise of the far right, courtesy of Lesbians and Gays Support the Migrants


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Have you ever heard of a ‘crazy ex-boyfriend’?

-
Image
Spoiler alert: don’t read if you intend to read/watch “The Girl on the Train” I just saw the film adaptation of the British bestseller “The Girl on the Train” and it made me see more clearly the utterly political aspect of the ‘crazy ex-girlfriend’ trope. The film shows an alcoholic woman who is gaslighted by her (former) husband into thinking that she is prone to angry and violent outbursts during her drinking blackouts. The manipulation not only makes her doubt her sanity, but leads her to think she killed another woman. Although I do not really care for the thriller and crime story aspect of the film, I found it interesting because it resonates with the white western misogynist and racist ideal of emotional restraint that hurts so many people (the ‘crazy ex-girlfriend’ trope, the ‘angry black woman’ trope, etc.). Emotions are political folks, and let’s pause for a second to thank second-wave feminists for pointing it out so clearly to us, despite all the shortcomings of t
Read more

The expectation that you will place yourself in a 'one down' position

-
"Deference - or the capacity to place oneself in a 'one down' position vis-à-vis others - is a characteristic demanded of all those in disadvantaged structural positions, including women, racial-ethnic minorities, and others in subordinate structural statuses. When deference is made a job requirement, members of structurally disadvantaged groups are likely to be overrepresented in such jobs or even be seen as better suited for the work than members of more advantaged groups." Amy S. Wharton (2009), "The Sociology of Emotional Labor", The Annual Review of Sociology, 36: 147-165.
Read more

Women attribute success to external factors, such as luck, men attribute their success to their own abilities

-
"Women who are career-oriented tend to have high self-esteem and self-confidence, and this factor is predictive of women's career achievements, especially in male-dominated occupations such as scientist or politician. Women generally tend to underestimate themselves, whereas men usually tend to overestimate their abilities and performance. This pattern is linked to women's tendency to attribute success to external factors, such as luck, whereas men attribute their success to their own abilities, (...). Women tend to attribute their failures to internal sources, such as lack of ability or effort, whereas men excuse failure by external factors, such as bad luck", Catherine Hakim (2000),  Work-Lifestyle Choices in the 21st Century,  Oxford, Oxford University Press: 186.
Read more